Monday, April 22, 2013

Overreaction or Underreaction

I’ve been wrestling all week about the Boston bombings (to recap, this week has been very tumultuous as not only was there a Texas fertilizer plant that blew up killing 14 people, the running of the Boston Marathon was interrupted on Monday, Patriots’ Day, by bombings along the route that were perpetrate by unknown terrorists until Thursday night, when a massive all-day manhunt throughout Boston started and concluded with one of the suspects shot dead and another taken into custody). If I was look at the death count, it’s not such a tremendous impact: several dead, lots injured, many lost limbs, arms, etc. A younger, more callous version of myself would have just stopped there with that counter-sentiment: “It wasn’t really that big a deal, the American public is overreacting, the media has blown it way out of proportion (not intended to be a pun) due to the urban setting and sensationalist manhunt that occurred.” There’s something to be said for that: terrorist attacks happen all the time in other countries, bombings in public areas and mass hysteria, certainly exerting a death and injury toll higher than that witnessed in Boston. In fact, in China this week many hundreds died due to an earthquake. Are those lives that are lost in the earthquake less important than the ones lost in the Boston bombings? I would think not. All deaths and injuries are not to be taken lightly. And as an American I wouldn’t want to confirm the stereotypical view that Americans feel invincible, like they are superior to others and can’t be hurt, or that their lives are more precious than citizens of other countries. So that would be one side to the argument, that I and most of America is are overreacting to this event.
                The argument for why I might be UNDERreacting to this news, though, is that this is not a normal bombing. This is a trend to something bigger, that random people throughout America, for whatever reason, whether they’re disgruntled at someone specific or angry at the world or whatever, can cause mass killings and create great chaos and put many, many people in harm’s way. Perhaps this is just a piece of a bigger picture, of a society that’s increasingly harboring citizens that become so delusional and ill-witted but with such tremendous means to create great destruction that it’s becoming too big of a problem. I don’t know if other decades, time periods, and eras had this much random violence, but certainly the last few years or so has seen a flurry of these kinds of random mass terrorist-like acts, whether in Aurora, Colorado, Gabby Giffords in Arizona, last December’s Newtown, Connecticut shootings, and now this. It’s really a disturbing sign that although very random, and having a minimal chance of happening to you yourself, that we’ve lost control of the ability to keep these maniacs, lunatics, or illdoers away from themselves or their distorted ideals, that we have to accept these ground rules (that you might be subject to mass violence in a very public place) at any time. It is very tragic and very disturbing, and I fear that I might be UNDERREACTING to this news. I’m really worried that these random attacks will surpass earthquakes and others in the sphere of consciousness as the most feared killers. Also, think about this specific Boston bombing: Done at the end of a sporting event for charity, where most of the participants are running for some cause, have been drawn by the publicity of the event to contribute to society and do good, basically the best members of society being singled out by these bombers and targeted to their detriment. It’s really a shame and sends a very bad message to the public as a whole. Let’s stop this.
Since this is a fantasy blog though and there have been 3 weeks of baseball in the books, let’s do a theme of overreaction/underreaction to some of the slow starts and hot streaks at the beginning of the season and evaluate early season trends.

1.)    Some marginal pitchers that people might be underreacting to are Paul Maholm (man just look at that strikeout rate), Hisashi Iwakuma (great environment), Carlos Villanueva (no pressure in the right league). Many are touting them as “regressing to the mean” candidates, but sometimes pitchers just breakout, and we may be seeing the beginning of great years.
2.)    LOT of overreaction on Mike Trout. Remember at this time last year he hadn’t even taken a major league at-bat yet. Still 35 HR, 40 SB at least, I’d say.
3.)    Generally, don’t overreact to any proven hitters who have put up similar numbers for 4 or more years. These are guys who, whatever they’re going through, have “gone through it” before, and have figured it out.  Don’t worry about Matt Kemp’s “recovery from injury,” Joey Votto’s lack of power, Ryan Braun’s slow start (geez, if you’re worried about Ryan Braun other than possible suspension you don’t know fantasy baseball)
4.)    Do worry about those hitters if they’re getting too old. A buddy of mine recently told me Albert Pujols has regressed to the point he has to “cheat on a fastball,” which indicates loss of bat speed, rapid regression, etc. Bad news for Angels, bad news for fantasy owners.
5.)    John Buck- we might all be underreacting here. Every once in a while a 30+ guy has a year that he’s never done before and no one ever saw coming (see Esteban Loaiza, Edwin Encarnacion). For some owners, he might be so obvious of a pickup (more than 10 RBI’s more than the closest competitor on waiver wire) that people don’t want to pick him up. If he’s on some waiver wires,  Grab him.
6.)    Coco Crisp: Ok, now here’s a guy who will never hit for much power, his 5 HR’s will probably be half of his season total. Don’t overreact.
7.)    Dexter Fowler: Seems like a legitimate breakout to me. Good park, good lineup protection, good pedigree. Overreact. Go wild.
8.)    Jed Lowrie/Michael Morse All Oakland and Seattle hitters. Those parks will gobble their stats alive.
9.)    Not that many closer changes in the MLB yet (unlike last year, when a lot). Don’t overreact and pay a high price in a trade for a closer. New closers are coming, trust me. Managers are impatient to win and will have itchy trigger fingers.
10.) Don’t underreact to the “passing of the torch” at the top of the hitter rankings, names like Bryce Harper, Justin Upton, Carlos Gonzalez, and Adam Jones. These are the new hitting hierarchy, and we just need to get used to them.

FFantasize on, 

Robert Yan  

No comments: